Large site logo

To Open The Sky

The Front Pages of Christopher P. Winter
Work in progress

The Republican Party's Ruinous Revolt

In his 2018 book Trumpocracy: The Corruption of the American Republic, David Frum observed:

“Maybe you do not care much about the future of the Republican Party. You should. Conservatives will always be with us. If conservatives become convinced that they can not win democratically, they will not abandon conservatism. They will reject democracy.”

Conservatives prove how correct Frum was almost every day. For decades, they have been ignoring the wishes of the populace — the demos. Their goal is to rule, not to govern.

Changes to election laws

In addition to making it harder to vote, and confusing or intimidating voters with misinformation and threats, Republicans are amking changes to the way states control elections. For example, in Georgia the Republican-controlled legislature has essentially removed final auhority to certifyy elections from secretary of state Brad Raffensperger. In Nebraska, an attempt to restore that state to a traditional winner-take-all status for electoral-college votes failed.

This revolt continues in various states where GOP-led legislatures attempt to consolidate power unto themselves. The conservative majority Trump and Mitch McConnell manuevered onto the Supreme Court, and onto lower courts, backstops this revolt.

I regret that I am out of time to provide more detail on this aspect of their scheme.

Georgia

"I just want to find 11,780 votes, which is one more than we have..."

You may remember this request, made by Trump in a call to Georgia election officials after he lost the state in 2020. Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger, to his everlasting credit, refused to go along. But Raffensperger, and Gov. David Kemp, still support Trump -- as does the state legislature, which passed SB 202. Saying the bill makes it "easy to vote and hard to cheat," Gov. Kemp signed it immediately.

The bill does make it easier to vote in some ways. But here is how it makes voting harder.:

  • Anyone wanting an absentee ballot must provide a driver's license or other identification. Those lacking a driver's license or state ID must verify their identity in some other way.
  • Drop boxes must be inside early voting locations. They will no longer be in libraries or other government buildings, locations convenient for many voters. Also, no drop boxes will be available for the final four days of an election.
  • Each county must have a minimum of one drop box. But there are also maximum limits. These can reduce the number of drop boxes in larger counties. For example, Atlanta's Fulton County would go from 38 drop boxes down to just 8.
  • A runoff election will now take place four weeks after the general election, versus nine weeks.
  • The early voting period for runoffs will shrink from three weeks to one.
  • Absentee ballots will be sent to voters 29 days before an election, versus 49 days prior.
  • Requests for absentee ballots can be made 78 days before the election, versus 180 days.
  • Volunteers will be prohibited from offering food, water and folding chairs to voters waiting in long lines. (The rationale was to prevent anyone trying to influence voters.)
  • The law allows a citizen to challenge the elgilbility to vote of an unlimited number of other citizens.

Note that the claimed justification for this bill was concern over tampering with the election. This despite three recounts of votes in Georgia's 2020 presidential election, with no significant problem found.

Then in May 2024, Gov. Kemp signed Senate Bill 189 into law, adding still more restrictions. They include:

  • Homeless individuals will have their mailing address for elections set as the registrar's office in their county.
  • Registering to vote in another state or municipality will count as a change of residence. If the voter returns to the original district, they must renew their registration.
  • Having proof of renting a post office box or private mail service will no longer count as proof of residency for voting purposes.

In addition, both measures exapnd the opportunities for citizens to challenge voter eligibility...

Both these laws have been challenged by the ACLU and other organizations.

References:

  1. Georgia again certifies election results showing Biden won (Kate Brumback, AP News, 7 December 202)
  2. Georgia reaffirms Biden's victory for 3rd time after recount, dealing major blow to Trump's attempt to overturn the results (Chandelis Duster, CNN, 7 December 202)
  3. Here's what Donald Trump asked Georgia election officials in phone call about 2020 election (Michael Li & Amy Sherman, Politico, 25 July 2023)
  4. Georgia's 'Jim Crow' voter suppression bill is now law. Here's how Democrats can fight back. (Teri Kanefield, THINK, 28 March 2021)
  5. Georgia governor signs sweeping election regulations into law. There are even restrictions on snacks. (Jane C. Timm, NBC News, 25 March 2021)
  6. Georgia's restrictive new voting law, explained (Zack Beauchamp, Vox, 26 March 2021)
  7. The DOJ's lawsuit against Georgia's voter suppression law is probably doomed (Ian Millhiser, Vox, 26 June 2021)
  8. What Georgia's Voting Law Really Does (Nick Corasaniti and Reid J. Epstein, New York Times, 18 April 2021)
  9. Georgia Promised to Fix How Voter Challenges Are Handled. A New Law Could Make the Problem Worse. (Doug Bock Clark, ProPublica, 10 May 2023)
  10. New law removes Secretary of State from Elections Board, adds voter challenge options (Sam Sacks, WSB-TV, 8 May 2024)
  11. How Republicans Could Block a Democratic Victory in Georgia (Ari Berman, National Voting Rights Consultant, Mother Jones, 19 September 2024)
  12. Why Hand Counting Ballots Could Create an Election Disaster (Philip Elliot, Time, 9 October 2024)

Nebraska

The tradition with electoral-college votes is that each state awarded all its EC votes to the candidate who got the majority of the popular vote. After the 2020 election, two states, Maine and Nebraska, changed to a proportional system. What this means in 2024 is that in the very red state of Nebraska Trump would get one fewer EC vote than he would have under the traditional system.

The measure to reverse this, introduced in April, failed because of opposition from Republican legislators.

With Trump's support, state Republicans again endeavored to reverse this on short notice, figuring that Maine would not follow suit so close to the election. However, this new try also failed due to Republican holdouts.

References:

  1. Nebraska Lawmakers Vote Down 'Winner-Take-All' Electoral System Change (Chase Porter, KLIN, 4 April 2024)
  2. Nebraska lawmakers overwhelmingly reject Trump-backed 'winner-take-all' electoral system (Nick Robertson, MSN, 4 April 2024)
  3. Republicans step up effort to change Nebraska's electoral vote process to benefit Trump (Brittany Shepherd & Isabella Murray, ABC News, 19 September 2024)
  4. Key Nebraska Republican opposes Trump effort to change state's electoral vote process (Brittany Shepherd & Alexandra Hutzler, ABC News, 23 September 2024)
  5. A GOP push to change how Nebraska awards its electoral votes appears to have stalled (NPR Washington Desk, 23 September 2024)
  6. Nebraska governor ends push to change the way state awards electoral votes in blow to Trump (Terence Burlij & Jeff Zeleny, CNN, 25 September 2024)
  7. The GOP's Nebraska plan to beat Kamala Harris just hit a wall (Hayes Brown, MSNBC Opinion Writer/Editor, 23 September 2024)
  8. Trump scheme ENDS IN DISASTER as Republicans scramble (Brian Tyler Cohen, Democracy Watch, 27 September 2024)

Late-Breaking News

With just days to go, Republicans are mounting a flurry of last-minute legal actions to gum up the works in the presidential campaign. Here are some examples (along with general references):

Donald Trump is suing CBS over a 60 Minutes interview with Kamala Harris that he claims is deceptive.

The Republican National Committee is asking the Supreme Court to Stop Pennsylvania from counting certain absentee ballots.

Some 130 lawsuits have been filed. This flurry of cases argues that RNC strategy is shifting to litigation because they know the voter tide is turning against them.

References:

  1. Trump Sues CBS News for Editing an Interview . . . With Kamala Harris?! (Steve Shires, 1 November 2024)
  2. Republicans pulling STUNNING stunt at US Supreme Court (Brian Tyler Cohen, Democracy Watch, 1 November 2024)
  3. How Courts Are Impacting 2024 Election: Pennsylvania County's Early Voting Extended After Trump Campaign Sues (Allison Durkee, Forbes, 30 October 2024)
  4. GOP's aggressive court strategy sets the stage to cast doubt on the 2024 results (Tierney Sneed & Devan Cole, CNN , 28 October 2024)
  5. Republican Legal Challenges to Voting Rules Hit a Rough Patch (Michael Corkery, New York Times, 25 October 2024)
  6. Battleground states flooded with voting lawsuits weeks out from Election Day (Adam Edelman, NBC News, 23 October 2024)
  7. Republicans are challenging all aspects of mail-in voting in battleground states (Casey Gannon & Paula Reid, CNN, 9 October 2024)

General References

  1. Republicans Seize on False Theories About Immigrant Voting (Alexandra Berzon, New York Times, 5 September 2024)
  2. GOP lawsuits set the stage for state challenges if Trump loses the election (Nicholas Riccardi, AP News, 5 September 2024)
  3. Republicans are suing more election officials over voter rolls in several battleground states (Devan Cole, CNN, 20 September 2024)
  4. Key Nebraska Republican opposes Trump effort to change state's electoral vote process (Brittany Shepherd & Alexandra Hutzler, ABC News, 23 September 2024)
  5. A GOP push to change how Nebraska awards its electoral votes appears to have stalled (NPR Washington Desk, 23 September 2024)
  6. The GOP's Nebraska plan to beat Kamala Harris just hit a wall (Hayes Brown, MSNBC Opinion Writer/Editor, 23 September 2024)
  7. Nebraska governor ends push to change the way state awards electoral votes in blow to Trump (Terence Burlij & Jeff Zeleny, CNN, 25 September 2024)
  8. Trump Allies Bombard the Courts, Setting Stage for Post-Election Fight Danny Hakim, Alexandra Berzon & Nick Corasaniti, New York Times, 29 September 2024)
  9. Why Legal Experts Are Worried About a Second Trump Presidency (Emily Bazelon & Mattathias Schwartz, New York Times, 3 October 2024)
  10. Trump's 2024 Blueprint for Stealing the White House (Greg Palast, The Thom Hartmann Program, 14 October 2024)
  11. GOP Lawsuits Target Swing State Voters Overseas—Including Military Members (Marc Elias, Democracy Docket, 16 October 2024)
  12. Marc Elias: This Will Be the Most Litigious Election in American History (Marc Elias, Democracy Docket, 17 October 2024)
  13. In this last segment of MSNBC Prime, Marc Elias and a lawyer formerly with the Brennan Center for Justice describe the Republicans' litigation campaign. (Nicolle Wallace, MSNBC, 20 October 2024)
  14. Elon Musk Is A Threat To Democracy (Leeja Miller, Why, America?, 21 October 2024)
  15. Former DOJ Official Warns of Potential "Election Crisis" (Hari Srinavasa, Amanpour&Co, 22 October 2024)
  16. Norm Eisen, Marc Elias & Key Secretaries of State on Election Concerns, Solutions & Certification ((Marc Elias, Democracy Watch, 24 October 2024)
  17. What to Know About the Looming Election Certification Crisis (Jim Rutenberg, New York Times, 25 October 2024)
  18. Republican caught on camera calling for AUTOMATIC Trump win in swing state (Marc Elias, Democracy Watch, 28 October 2024)
  19. The Lawsuits That Could Decide the 2024 Election (Sophie Feldman, Democracy Docket, 29 October 2024)
  20. An army of election officials ready to reject the vote: NYT Magazine (Jim Rutenberg & Bob Woodward, Morning Joe, 30 October 2024)

Now that you have (I hope) read some or all of the content of those links, a big question arises: Why does any of this matter? It matters because Republican politicians — with a few notable exceptions —are not helping the people they are supposed to serve: their constituents. When those Republicans are in Congress, their misbehavior afects the whole nation and even foreign countries. I won't go into detail here, but see the links I provide below.

Many people think both major parties are the same. It is true that the Democratic Party has fallen short of its traditional support for working people. But Joe Biden's victory in 2020 began to reverse that trend. On the bread-and0-butter issues that affect the daily lives of most Americans, the Biden administration has made solid improvements: cut child poverty in half, relieved many college debts, launched massive infrastructure improvement, capped drug prices for seniors, created record numbers of jobs, reduced ACA healthcare premiums, strengthened the hands of labor union organizers, and reauthorized the Violence Against Women Act. Again, see the links below for details.

The Republican Party, by contrast, has been a party of words and not of deeds. They blame Democrats for "destroying the country" and — like Trump himself — constantly accuse them of "weaponizing the Justice Department with "politically motivated prosecutions" against him. What they have done in legislative measures mostly benefits the rich — like Trump's major achievement, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017.

And when it comes to voting rights, they are — as David Frum noted — opposed. That opposition is what I will examine in these pages. The first set of links below are prime sources for daily updates.

This source on YouTube is excellent for daily updates on the fast changing situation.

I regret that I can only touch here on the many ways Republicans have changed state election procedures to make it easier to nullify the unwanted outcome of an election. The details of these clashes and misdirections are complicated and evolve daily.

Here's the takeaway: While the Democratic Party is not blameless, this interference with legitimate governance is coming mainly from Republicans. They care nothing about their constitutional duties or the will of the people. They only want to rule, not to govern.

Note.    ***    Remember.    ***    Vote.

Valid CSS! Valid HTML 4.01 Strict To contact Chris Winter, send email to this address.
Copyright © 2023-2024 by Christopher P. Winter. All rights reserved.
Created 7 September 2023. This page was last modified on 14 November 2024.