RIVER OF NO RETURN

Reviewed 7/27/2016

Blu-ray cover

RIVER OF NO RETURN
DIRECTED BY: Otto Preminger
Genre: WESTERNS
Major Cast
Robert Mitchumas Matt Calder
Marilyn Monroeas Kay Weston
Rory Calhounas Harry Weston
Tommy Rettigas Mark Calder
Murvyn Vyeas Dave Colby
Douglas Spenceras Sam Benson
Remainder uncredited (listed alphabetically)
Fred Aldrichas Prospector
Claire Andreas Surrey Driver
Hal Bayloras Young Punk
Don Beddoeas Ben, the shopkeeper
Ralph Buckoas Council City barfly
Roy Buckoas Prospector
Larry Chanceas Young Punk
John Cliffas Leering Man
Edmund Cobbas Barber
Cecil Combsas Prospector
John Doucetteas Man in Saloon
Tex Driscollas Prospector
Geneva Grayas Dance Hall Girl
Al Haskellas Wagon Driver
Ed Hintonas Gambler
Michael Jeffersas Prospector
Dick Johnstoneas Prospector
Mitchell Kowallas Prospector
Richard LaMarras Prospector
Anthony Lawrenceas Young Punk
Jarma Lewisas Saloon Dancer
Jack Lowas Prospector
Hank Mannas Council City Townsman
Jack Matheras Card Table Dealer
Ann McCreaas Dance Hall Girl
Harry Montyas Minor Role
Fay Morleyas Dancer
Charles Mortonas Prospector
Paul Newlanas Prospector
Barbara Nicholsas Blonde Dancer
George Patayas Council City Barfly
Jack Perrinas Prospector
Joe Phillipsas Prospector
Robert Robinsonas Prospector
John Royas Prospector
Danny Sandsas Prospector
Ralph Sanfordas Bartender
Harry Seymouras Pianist
Arthur Shieldsas Minister at Tent City
Cap Somersas Council City Barfly
George Sowardsas Council City Barfly
Jack Tornekas Prospector
John Veitchas Young Punk
Bob Whitneyas Council City Barfly
Harry Wilsonas Prospector
Will Wrightas Young Punk
MPAA Rating:Approved
Distributor:Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation
Production Companies:Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation
Release Date (US):4/30/1954
Domestic Box Office:$?
Foreign Box Office:$?
Production Budget:$2,195,000 (Est.)
Crew
PRODUCED BY: Stanley Rubin
DIRECTED BY: Otto Preminger
Screenplay:Frank Fenton
Story:Louis Lantz
Original Music:Cyril J. Mockridge
Leigh Harline (uncred.)
Vocal Director:Ken Darby
Musical Director:Lionel Newman
Cinematography:Joseph LaShelle
Visual Effects:Ray Kellogg
Film Editing:Louis R. Loeffler
Sound Department:Bernard Freericks
Roger Heman Sr.
Casting:Janet Hirshenson
Jane Jenkins
Production Design:Jane Musky
Art Direction:Addison Hehr
Lyle R. Wheeler
Set Decoration:Chester Bayhi
Walter M. Scott
Costume Design:Travilla
Wardrobe Director:Charles Le Maire
Choreographer:Jack Cole
Technicolor Consultant:Leonard Doss
Animal Supervisor:Ralph Helfer

PLOT SUMMARY

Matt Calder is a farmer working to clear trees on his homestead. Shortly he saddles his horse and rides down to a mining camp1, a journey that takes two or three days. There he searches for his young son Mark, whom he's asked a friend to bring to the tent city. It seems Matt has been away for quite a while, during which time his wife died. He finds ten-year-old Mark in the care of Kay Weston, a dance-hall girl, because the man who brought him there caught gold fever and lit out for the hills.

Kay's fiancé is Harry Weston, a gambler who's just won a gold claim himself in a poker game. Now he must get to Council City to file the claim, travelling through indian country. He has no horse, and nobody will sell him one. But he persuades Kay to give him the little money she's saved up; it's enough to buy a raft, on which he and Kay soon set off downriver to file that claim.

Calder, a man of few words, intends to leave town with Mark at once. But he relents and allows the boy to say his farewell to Kay. As they head back to the farm on Matt's horse, he promises the boy he'll teach him to hunt and fish. "And shoot?" asks Mark. Yes, agrees his father, that too. They've barely begun this when Mark spots the raft nearly foundering in the swift currents. Telling Mark to bring the horse, Matt runs to the shore with a rope and manages to get it to Harry. With the horse's help, they pull the raft to safety. After Matt makes it clear that Harry and Kay have no chance to survive the river's rapids, Harry offers to buy Matt's horse and rifle so he can make the trip overland. Matt refuses; he'd be as good as dead without them. So Harry repays Matt by stealing the rifle and horse, They fight; Matt is injured. Kay insists on staying with him and the boy, telling Harry he'll get to Council City twice as fast without her. Harry is convinced; he sets out.

Matt, being a tough guy, recovers quickly. But he has no choice now; without a rifle, he cannot fight the indians he sees constantly watching from the high ridges. Even as he, Kay, and Mark are boarding the raft, they make their attack. But the swift river carries the raft out of range of their arrows. It is an arduous passage, during which they must forage for food and face down a puma and hostile prospectors. They gradually grow closer, and learn some of each other's secrets — including the reason Matt was away so long.

Finally, after surviving indian raids and hazardous rapids, they reach Council City. This may be the most perilous passage of all, for Matt is determined to face Harry and get justice, while Kay is still set on marrying him.

The marvelous exterior shots are one of the best features of this film. They were taken along Idaho's Salmon River as well as Canada's Bow, Maligne, and Snake Indian Rivers and in Alberta's Banff and Jasper National Parks. But what really makes the film worth watching is the byplay between Mitchum and Monroe as their characters, under the pressures of the journey downriver, gradually shed their mutual distrust. Mitchum, it is true, sticks fairly close to his standard tough-guy persona; but Monroe give us a role with some depth, very different from the sexpot she is known for portraying. (She does give us that sort of performance, of course, in the several saloon scenes. These struck me as somewhat hokey. Perhaps that was intended.)

Tommy Retting is endearing as Mark, and Rory Calhoun, in the role of smooth-talking gambler Harry Weston, gives us a believable bad guy. The numerous other players, credited or uncredited, hold up their end as well. Minor plot holes exist,2 but they do not IMO detract from the film, which remains a very watchable one.

My Rating:
8 out of 10

Capsule review: It is the byplay between Mitchum and Monroe that lifts River of No Return above the level of standard formulaic western entertainment. That, plus credible performances by the other actors, gorgeous Canadian scenery, and some well-executed plot twists.

IMDB Rating: 6.7 Raters: 7,676
1 A wretched hive of scum and villainy...
2 The most obvious is that they would not have survived those rapids if they had actually traversed them, and would certainly have lost Kay's guitar very early on as it was apparently not lashed down. The other hole comes at the end of the film: Kay persuades Harry to leave his pistol behind when he meets Matt, and he makes a show of leaving it on the bar; but when he does face Matt it's still in his holster. (Of course, this could be laid to sleight of hand; he is a card sharp after all.)
Valid CSS! Valid HTML 4.01 Strict To contact Chris Winter, send email to this address.
Copyright © 2016-2021 Christopher P. Winter. All rights reserved.
This page was last modified on 13 March 2021.