GONE WITH THE WIND

Reviewed 9/01/2015

DVD Cover

GONE WITH THE WIND
DIRECTED BY: Victor Fleming
Genre: WAR DRAMAS
Major Cast (89 more uncredited)
Thomas Mitchellas Gerald O'Hara
Barbara O'Neillas Ellen - His Wife
Vivien Leighas Scarlett - Their Daughter
Evelyn Keyesas Suellen - Their Daughter
Ann Rutherfordas Carreen - Their Daughter
George Reevesas Brent Tarleton - Scarlett's Beau
Fred Craneas Stuart Tarleton - Scarlett's Beau
Hattie McDanielas Mammy - House Servant
Oscar Polkas Pork - House Servant
Butterfly McQueenas Prissy - House Servant
Victor Joryas Jonas Wilkerson - Field Overseer
Everett Brownas Big Sam - Field Foreman
Howard C. Hickmanas John Wilkes
Alicia Rhettas India - His Daughter
Leslie Howardas Ashley - His Son
Olivia de Havillandas Melanie Hamilton - Their Cousin
Rand Brooksas Charles Hamilton - Her Brother
Carroll Nyeas Frank Kennedy - A Guest
Clark Gableas Rhett Butler - Visitor from Charleston
Laura Hope Crewsas Aunt 'Pittypat' Hamilton
Eddie 'Rochester' Andersonas Uncle Peter - Her Coachman
Harry Davenportas Dr. Meade
Leona Robertsas Mrs. Meade
Jane Darwellas Mrs. Merriwether
Ona Munsonas Belle Watling
Paul Hurstas Yankee Deserter
Isabel Jewellas Emmy Slattery
Cammie King Conlonas Bonnie Blue Butler
Eric Lindenas Amputation Case
J.M. Kerriganas Johnny Gallagher
Ward Bondas Tom - Yankee Captain
Jackie Moranas Phil Meade
Cliff Edwardsas Reminiscent Soldier
Lillian Kemble-Cooperas Bonnie's Nurse in London
Yakima Canuttas Renegade
Marcella Martinas Cathleen Calvert
Louis Jean Heydtas Hungry Soldier holding Beau Wilkes
Mickey Kuhnas Beau Wilkes
Olin Howlandas A Carpetbagger Businessman
Irving Baconas Yankee Corporal
Robert Elliottas Yankee Major
William Bakewellas Mounted Officer
Mary Andersonas Maybelle Merriwether
MPAA Rating:G
Distributor:MGM (film); Warner Brothers (video)
Production Company:Selznick International Pictures
Release Date (US):17 Jan. 1940
Domestic Box Office:$198,655,459 (Mojo)
Foreign Box Office:$201,500,000 (Mojo)
Production Budget:$3,977,000 (Est.)

PLOT SUMMARY

At Tara, a luxurious plantation outside Atlanta, the O'Haras, Gerald and Ellen, have raised three beautiful daughters, of whom Scarlett is the most impulsive and willful. She has numerous beaus among the local boys, and when Captain Rhett Butler chances to visit he is smitten with her as well. But it is the eve of the Civil War, and soon their comfortable existence is swept aside. The young men march off wearing gray. Captain Butler is a blockade runner, and he too joins the effort. The cause is lost; the men trickle back, some wounded, some in caskets. Shortly comes General Sherman to raze Atlanta, and then the hated carpetbaggers arrive. The family is scattered, Tara abandoned. When after several years Scarlett staggers back with a few servants, she finds it intact but stripped. She and her companions must all work to survive: washing, tending the sick, planting and harvesting a meager garden, delivering a baby or two. Scarlett is hard-pressed but finds a reservoir of strength within herself.

Gradually, things improve. Captain Butler appears again, amid a tumult of interpersonal relationships, to further complicate things when he declares his love for Scarlett. Then, he's off again. The next time she sees him he is in a Yankee prison. But he soon bribes his way out of that with some of the wealth he piled up during the blockade-running years. Eventually they begin a tumultuous marriage, raise a daughter, and lose her to a stupid accident. This triggers agonizing excesses of angst, followed by temporary separations, until Rhett finally walks away after delivering the famous line about not giving a damn.

Gone with the Wind is indisputably an epic. Everything about it surpasses the typical film: the elegance and variety of the sets; the richness of the costumes; the devastation of Atlanta's bombardment; the violence waged by, and on, renegade Yankees; the poverty and privation suffered by the residents of Tara in the aftermath of conquest; and the emotional suffering they feel when relationships fall apart. It even surpasses other films in running time, at 238 minutes. It won ten Academy Awards and is deservedly on the National Film Register.

All that said, however, it struck me as a glorified soap opera. I don't fault any aspect of its production; all are top-notch. I simply don't like it; it is not my kind of film. One specific fault that struck me is that the scenes where husbands construed faithlessness on the part of their wives, or vice-versa, seemed contrived. For example, at one point Mr. Kennedy (?) is embracing Scarlett because she is distressed at the tumult that has engulfed the South. Kennedy's wife enters the room, takes one look and assumes the worst.

My Rating:
8 out of 10

Capsule review: This film is big in all respects. It has a large cast, expansive sets, impressive effects, emotive acting. It is rightly called a spectacular. But the number of characters can be confusing. I found it hard to keep the husbands straight. For all its magnificence, Gone with the Wind strongly resembles a glorified soap opera.

IMDB Rating: 8.2 Raters: 213,911
1 Ridley Scott has gone public with an answer to this question: It's because we put a man from Galilee on a cross at Golgotha 2,000 years ago. That man was one of them, it seems. They decided we are incorrigible.
Valid CSS! Valid HTML 4.01 Strict To contact Chris Winter, send email to this address.
Copyright © 2015-2021 Christopher P. Winter. All rights reserved.
This page was last modified on 12 March 2021.