BRIGHT GREEN LIES

Reviewed 9/18/2021

Bright Green Lies, by Jensen, Keith, & Wilbert

BRIGHT GREEN LIES
How the Environmental Movement Lost Its Way and What We Can Do About It
Derrick Jensen, Lierre Keith, & Max Wilbert
Rhinebeck, NY: Monkfish Book Publishing Co., March 2021

Rating:

4.0

High

ISBN-13 978-1-948626-39-2
ISBN-10 1-948626-39-X 478pp. SC/GSI $24.95

Errata

Page xvii: "We can't build soil, but the slow circling of bacteria, bison, and sweetgrass do."
  Number error: S/B "does".
Page 7: "The number of things we can store simultaneously in our brains—which have been two million years in the making—turns out to be a humble four."
  I believe the number should be six.
Page 13: "Two thousand years has not been enough time to heal the damage from the mine."
  Number error: S/B "have".
Page 107: "Let's change a few of her words: 'So the issue is, global warming deniers bright greens understand that if the science is true, their whole ideological project falls apart..."
  Making Naomi Klein say things she would never say is an attempt to turn her into a straw woman. It is a cheap shot.
Page 107: "Two thousand years has not been enough time to heal the damage from the mine."
  Number error: S/B "have".
Page 128: "This is what green energy is made from: the dust of shattered mountains, lakes of acid, and the agony of our winged and scaled kin."
  One example of the loaded language typical of the book.
Page 217: "This place is still rich in life, even in the midst of the biotic cleansing that has been underway for centuries here, millennia around the world."
  Missing space: S/B "under way".
Page 233: "The low concentrations of sodium and potassium in this particular limestone means the cement can withstand the corrosive effects of saltwater and therefore lasts longer in the ocean."
  Number error: S/B "low concentration".
Page 375: "Transmission corridors fragment habitat just like roads do, slicing the land into smaller, more isolated pieces."
  No, not like roads do — at least not for animals. Once plant cover grows back on the cleared corridor, I think even mice would cross it without much fear of predators. It's not like rubber tires will speed out of nowhere to run them down.
Page 403: "The group Saving Iceland writes that 'the exploitation of the Reykjanes peninsula's geothermal areas spells the end of this magnificent nature of the peninsula as we know it.' "
  Capitalization: S/B "the Reykjanes Peninsula's". Twice more on this page, the word "peninsula" is not capitalized when it should be.
Page 409: "Fish migration and spawning is disrupted."
  Number error: S/B "are".
Page 441: "In Estonia, small-scale peat bog restoration projects have been underway for many years."
  Missing space: S/B "under way".
Valid CSS! Valid HTML 4.01 Strict To contact Chris Winter, send email to this address.
Copyright © 2021 Christopher P. Winter. All rights reserved.
This page was last modified on 18 September 2021.