THE MAGIC FURNACE

Reviewed 5/24/2004

The Magic Furnace, by Marcus Chown

THE MAGIC FURNACE: The Search for the Origins of Atoms
Marcus Chown
Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001

Rating:

5.0

High

ISBN-13 978-0-19-514305-8
ISBN 0-19-514305-1 232pp. HC $25.00

The quest to understand the building blocks of matter began in Ancient Greece when, around 450 B.C., the sage Democritus first proposed that all things are made of tiny indivisible particles. It took more than 2,000 years before we began to understand what these particles, which Democritus called a-tomos (Greek for "uncuttable"), really are. Some of the scientists who contributed to this understanding are well known — Avogadro, Boltzmann, Boyle, Marie Curie, Lavoisier, Mendeleev, Rutherford, Thomson. In fact, the true nature of atoms was a hugely complex puzzle, one that took a host of investigators to unravel.1 Many of them are relatively obscure. One such is William Prout, who in 1815 guessed that atoms must be composed of still smaller parts.

As our understanding of atoms developed, another puzzle became apparent: What makes the Sun shine? It turns out that the answer to this puzzle is, at bottom, the same as the answer to what atoms are.

In The Magic Furnace, Marcus Chown traces this millennia-long quest up to the present. He divides the story into three parts. The basic discoveries, that atoms exist and can be detected, and that they are not after all indivisible, are the subject of Part One. Part Two focuses on sunlight, for, as they learned the true age of the Sun, scientists realized there was no known process that could keep it shining for so long — yet, it shines. Finally, unraveling this mystery led naturally to the third puzzle: how the wide variety of chemical elements came to be. And this is covered in Part Three.

Chown is cosmology consultant for the British magazine New Scientist and the author of a previous book, Afterglow of Creation, an award-winning explanation of the Big Bang. Here, in The Magic Furnace, he unfolds the millennia-long quest and its multitude of participants in what I think of as "old-school" fashion — as a series of connected episodes, each linked to the next by a one-sentence summary of the next facet of the problem to be investigated. I was most interested in Part Three, but I found the entire story fascinating and worth reading from the beginning. Chown enlivens his account with details of the scientists' personalities, incidents of competition and parallel discovery, and occasional happy accidents (as when Fred Hoyle,2 assigned to a wartime conference in Washington, DC, found he had three days free and could hop a train to Princeton, NJ and confer with astronomer Henry Norris Russell.) Heroes, too, appear in the narrative.3

A glossary, select bibliography, and an index4 are included. The book contains no illustrations. It would have benefitted from them, especially on page 15, where the first images of atoms, obtained by a scanning tunneling microscope, are described. In addition, there are a few errors, a few questionable statements (listed in my Errata page as usual). None of this, however, really detracts from the worth of the book. I recommend it unreservedly.

1 I've glossed over the truth here; for in fact the true nature of matter is still being unraveled. We know that the "elementary" particles, electrons, protons, neutrons and the rest of the zoo, are made of still more elementary quarks. Theories under development suggest that even quarks may have simpler components.
2 Hoyle is one of the more interesting scientists described. His "outrageous" contention that, since humans (based on carbon) existed, the nucleus of carbon-12 must have an undiscovered energy state at 7.65 MeV, led to the discovery of that state. It was in fact the birth of the Anthropic Principle, a source of controversy even today.
3 Perhaps the most heroic was Fritz Houtermans. Imprisoned in Stalin's Russia as a German spy, he was returned to Germany when the two nations became allies in 1940. Then he was handed over to the Gestapo, who held him as a communist spy. He later was freed through the intervention of Max von Laue. Joining the German nuclear program, he first saw the utility of plutonium for atomic bombs. Risking his life, he messaged American scientists: "Hurry up. We are on the track." In 1945, he actually persuaded the head of the program that heavy water could be extracted from Macedonian tobacco! (See page 111.) You have to admire a guy like that.
4 There are errors in the index. At least, the entry for Albert Einstein is inaccurate. However, I found it correct for every name I tried to look up except Einstein's.
Valid CSS! Valid HTML 4.01 Strict To contact Chris Winter, send email to this address.
Copyright © 2004-2024 Christopher P. Winter. All rights reserved.
This page was last modified on 28 July 2024.